The Supreme Court of Western Australia – Court of Appeal’s decision in ASIC v Jones1 provides additional welcome clarification on the issue of insolvency practitioner independence in the context of pre-administration services. The decision is broadly consistent with the decision in Ten Network2, in which the Federal Court of Australia held that a conflict of interest can be mitigated but not cured by disclosure and consent. However, the decision in ASIC v Jones provides further clarity on the factors that a Court will consider when assessing independence.
Background
The voluntary administrators were appointed to two companies, GD Pork Pty Ltd and GD Meats Pty Ltd in October 2018 (Companies).
Prior to their appointment, one of the voluntary administrators (via the practitioner’s firm) provided advice to the Companies over a period of 3 months immediately before the Companies were placed into administration. The practitioner’s firm was paid a fee of circa $100,000 for that advice, before the commencement of the voluntary administration.
ASIC alleged that the voluntary administrators lacked independence because of a conflict of interest. It was alleged the conflict of interest…